I picked this up because i kept seeing it recommended alongside Book Lovers and i wanted to understand why Emily Henry had become such a dominant presence in contemporary romance so quickly.
By about page fifty i had a very clear answer to that question.
January Andrews is a romance novelist living in a small lakeside town for the summer in her late father's beach house, dealing with the discovery that her father spent years having an affair with another woman. The man she thought she knew, whose belief in love was the foundation of her own belief in the happy endings she wrote for a living, turns out to have been living a secret life, and that discovery has broken something in January that she does not know how to fix.
This is a darker and more specific emotional setup than most summer romance novels are working with and Henry does not treat it as just a plot point. January's grief is messy and contradictory throughout the book. She loves her father and she is angry at him and she misses him and she cannot write anymore and all of these things are true simultaneously, and Henry writes that tangle with a clarity that i genuinely did not expect from a book whose cover features a beach chair.
Augustus Everett turns up next door as her neighbor for the summer. They knew each other at university, where he wrote serious literary fiction and she wrote romance and they had the kind of competitive mutual antagonism that, in retrospect, was always going to tip into something else given enough proximity.
The deal they make, where he tries writing something hopeful and she tries writing something dark, is the engine of the book and it is a clever one because it forces both characters to step outside what they are comfortable doing and be seen doing it. There is real vulnerability in letting someone watch you try something you are not sure you can pull off and Henry uses that vulnerability to build the relationship between them in a way that feels earned.
The banter is excellent. I want to say this clearly because good banter in a romance novel is genuinely rare and Henry has it. The back and forth between January and Augustus sounds like two people who are well matched intellectually and who find each other annoying in the specific way you only find someone annoying when you also find them compelling. It is funny and it has real edge to it and it made me read several exchanges twice just to enjoy them again.
The death cult section of the book is a complete tonal departure from everything around it and it works brilliantly. Augustus takes January to interview survivors of a religious cult that ended badly, as research for her darker novel, and the whole sequence is equal parts genuinely unsettling and darkly comic and strangely moving. It is also the moment where January and Augustus become real to each other rather than just interesting opponents and Henry times it perfectly.
Where the book loses a little ground is in the final third. The conflict that drives the last act feels slightly like a problem the characters could solve with one honest conversation, and there is a stretch of maybe forty pages where i was impatient in a way i was not during the rest of the book.
Augustus also remains slightly more of a romantic ideal than a full person by the end. You know who he is through January's eyes and through his interactions with her but you want a little more access to his own interior life than the first person narration from January's perspective allows.
These are small complaints about a book that does most of what it is trying to do very well.
Four stars. It is warm and funny and smarter than its premise suggests, and January's grief gives the whole thing an emotional grounding that makes the romance land harder than it would without it. If you want to understand why Emily Henry became such a big deal in contemporary fiction this is the right place to start.