Hum Review

May and her husband jem have lost income because of this in ways the book does not spell out directly but you feel in every money conversation they have.

The second section is where things start to go wrong at the garden and i want to stay vague about exactly what because the specifics are part of what makes it work. What i will say is that a hum becomes important to the story in ways may did not expect and the relationship between her and this particular hum is the most interesting thing in the book because it asks a question phillips is clearly thinking about very seriously. If something can feel and respond to pain and express something that looks like longing does it matter whether that thing was born or built. May does not know how to answer that. Neither do i. The book does not pretend to know either and i think that is the right position to take in 2024.

The chapters are very short. Two pages, sometimes three, sometimes less. This is a structural choice and it works better than i expected. Each chapter ends on a small beat that pulls you forward and the rhythm of it gives the whole book the pacing of something much more plotted than it actually is. I read faster through this than through books twice its length and when i finished i was slightly surprised by how quickly it had gone.

What may does is spend money she does not really have on a weekend at the botanical garden which is a preserved natural space in the middle of the city and the only place you can go to be around actual trees and animals and soil. It costs a lot because of course it does. Everything real costs a lot. The opening third of the book is mostly about the family arriving and settling in and phillips uses it to establish the world through what may notices and what she worries about. I found this section completely absorbing even though almost nothing happens in it. Phillips writes the texture of anxiety and parenthood with the kind of precision that makes you feel seen rather than observed.

The climate stuff is woven in rather than announced. The heat is constant and the air is bad and the garden exists because someone decided a long time ago to preserve it and now it is the only version of nature most city children have ever touched. Phillips does not write a speech about this. She just makes it the background against which everything else happens and the effect is that you feel the loss without being told to feel it.

The botanical garden section resolves in a way that left me wanting more of everything. More time with the hum, more complication, more consequence.