The Thursday Murder Club Review
| Published | 2020-09-22 |
| Series | Thursday Murder Club |
| Genre | Mystery, Cozy Crime |
| Language | English |
| Publisher | Pamela Dorman Books / Viking |
| ISBN-10 | 1984880969 |
| ISBN-13 | 9781984880963 |
📝The Thursday Murder Club — My Honest Review
Written and reviewed by Shadab Alam. The opinions and rating in this review are my own.
Summary:
Four residents of a retirement community investigate cold cases for fun until a local murder gives them a live investigation. Elizabeth's hidden past, Joyce's warm diary voice, and the group's use of age and underestimation create the charm. The story examines aging, friendship, loss, usefulness, memory, curiosity, and community through choices that become harder once their cost reaches other people.
✅ What I Liked
What worked for me was the friendship among the investigators, retirement-village setting, practical cleverness, humor, and grief. The book also benefits from this character choice: Elizabeth's hidden past, Joyce's warm diary voice, and the group's use of age and underestimation create the charm. I remembered the scenes around the friendship among the investigators more clearly than the larger speeches.
❌ What Could Be Better
The weaker part for me was that the mystery is more tangled than elegant, and shifts between comedy and sadness can be abrupt. It did not erase what worked in The Thursday Murder Club, though it made the structure feel more visible than I wanted.
Four residents of a retirement community investigate cold cases for fun until a local murder gives them a live investigation. That setup creates an immediate question about aging, yet the answer shifts once friendship becomes personal.
I became most involved through the people caught in aging, especially around the friendship among the investigators. Elizabeth's hidden past, Joyce's warm diary voice, and the group's use of age and underestimation create the charm. That contradiction made the emotional logic around aging believable, especially in scenes involving the friendship among the investigators.
The sections I enjoyed most involved the friendship among the investigators, retirement-village setting, practical cleverness, humor, and grief. These details, especially the friendship among the investigators, gave me something concrete to hold while the book dealt with aging.
I kept returning to aging, friendship, loss, usefulness, memory, curiosity, and community. The book is better when aging and friendship appear in behavior, especially in who gets believed and who carries the cost afterward.
My main reservation is that the mystery is more tangled than elegant, and shifts between comedy and sadness can be abrupt. I could accept some roughness, but this choice weakened the book's treatment of aging, especially after the friendship among the investigators.
The book leaves enough room for disagreement about aging, especially around the friendship among the investigators, which made my own reaction more precise.
I did not love every choice, but I believed The Thursday Murder Club's interest in aging. That interest in The Thursday Murder Club remained after the plot settled.
📊Shadab's Rating
🎭Vibe Check
Read spoilers, debates, and detailed user reviews in our discussion room.
Discover Your Next Great Read
Handpicked recommendations from our collection of literary treasures
