All the Beastly Things begins with an intriguing contradiction. Igraine lives in a society that believes it has escaped many of humanity’s old systems of domination, yet her own life is governed by strict rules, ritual, silence, hierarchy, and expectation. The women of the Order have inherited a world destroyed by earlier generations and built something they believe is safer in its place. Eilish Quin makes the unsettling possibility clear from the beginning: removing an old structure of power does not automatically prevent another one from taking its place.
Igraine is particularly effective as the center of the novel because she does not begin as an obvious rebel. She believes in the Order. She wants the honor of serving at the Lunar Abbey, and the religious system around her gives shape and purpose to everything she understands about herself. That makes her crisis of faith more convincing than a story in which the protagonist already recognizes the system as oppressive. Doubt arrives slowly, through relationships and contradictions that become harder to ignore.
Ophelia creates the first major fracture. Her visions of a male archangel are dangerous not simply because men have been erased from the society Igraine knows, but because the visions introduce the possibility that the Order’s version of history may be incomplete. Whether those visions should be understood as revelation, rebellion, desire, or something stranger matters less than what they force the two young women to question. Their friendship becomes a place where loyalty to another person begins competing with loyalty to an institution.
Sister Agathe adds a different form of pressure. Brilliant, intimidating, and intensely interested in Igraine, she represents the seduction of authority rather than its bluntest form. The novel becomes more interesting when power is expressed through mentorship, admiration, and the promise of becoming exceptional. Igraine does not merely fear disappointing the Order; part of her genuinely wants what it offers. That makes manipulation much harder to identify and much more emotionally complicated.
The worldbuilding is one of the book’s clearest strengths. The Lunar Abbey, religious codex, post-nuclear landscape, altered relationship with time, and biological consequences of living beyond Earth all give the setting a distinctive identity. Publishers Weekly specifically praised Quin for building a large speculative world without losing sight of the characters. The science-fiction elements matter because they constantly reinforce the novel’s larger question about what humans are willing to sacrifice in order to create a supposedly better society.
There is a risk, though, that the symbolic architecture becomes too visible. Religion, gender, bodily control, forbidden desire, history, and institutional secrecy are all working simultaneously, and readers who prefer subtle worldbuilding may occasionally feel the novel announcing its concerns before the characters have fully lived through them. The density of the setting can also make the early sections more demanding than the central friendship itself.
What ultimately gives the story weight is that Quin does not reduce the conflict to a simple argument between freedom and oppression. Igraine has been shaped by genuine relationships, knowledge, ritual, and community inside the Order. Discovering its darker foundations does not erase everything that once gave her life meaning. The harder question becomes whether someone can reject an institution without rejecting every part of themselves that institution helped create.
What I Liked
The strongest element is Igraine’s genuine faith in the world around her. She is not simply waiting for someone to expose the truth, which makes every new doubt more consequential. The relationship between Igraine and Ophelia also gives the larger ideological conflict a personal scale, while the Lunar Abbey and the altered post-apocalyptic society provide memorable speculative imagery without turning the novel into pure worldbuilding.
What Could Be Better
The novel carries a large number of themes at once, including religion, gender, desire, ecological collapse, technology, institutional control, and historical revision. That ambition gives the book depth, but it can also make some of the symbolism feel overly deliberate. The early worldbuilding requires patience, and readers looking primarily for fast-moving dystopian action may find the novel more reflective than expected.
Context Behind the Book
Eilish Quin is a writer and artist based in Los Angeles. She previously wrote Medea, a reimagining of the Greek myth that centers Medea’s perspective and examines how women labeled as monsters are represented. All the Beastly Things moves into speculative fiction while retaining Quin’s interest in gender, power, desire, mythology, and the stories societies construct around people who challenge accepted roles.