The Squatters builds its tension around a question that sounds simple until money, marriage, property, friendship, and personal risk become involved: what does helping another person actually require? Dalia believes she already knows what kind of person she is. She has experienced migration through her own family history, understands the language of compassion, and lives among people who would probably describe themselves as tolerant. Meeting Hajira forces those beliefs out of the comfortable realm of opinion and into a situation where somebody needs something concrete from her.
That distinction gives the novel its strongest material. Dalia can sympathize with refugees while remaining protected by wealth, citizenship, property, and social connections that Hajira and Yusuf do not have. Once she begins using those advantages on their behalf, the reactions around her reveal how quickly abstract generosity can disappear when it threatens somebody’s home, reputation, or sense of security. Brelvi is particularly effective when class divisions appear inside communities that outsiders might assume are politically or culturally unified.
Dalia is deliberately difficult to treat as an uncomplicated hero. Her desire to help is genuine, but guilt, memory, frustration, and a need to recover an earlier version of herself are mixed into that desire. That ambiguity improves the book because it prevents activism from becoming a simple badge of virtue. At the same time, the novel sometimes depends too heavily on Dalia making increasingly risky decisions to keep the situation escalating, and there are moments when her choices feel driven more by the needs of the plot than by fully developed conviction.
The relationship between Dalia and Hajira is most interesting when the book acknowledges the imbalance between them. Dalia has the privilege of deciding how much of herself she will risk; Hajira does not have the same freedom. Even an act of kindness can create another dependency when one person controls access to housing, institutions, and money. The novel becomes less convincing whenever that imbalance is simplified into friendship, but its better scenes keep the discomfort visible.
The surrounding social circle is where the characterization becomes more uneven. Brelvi needs people around Dalia who represent complacency, fear, status anxiety, and hostility toward migrants, yet some of those characters can feel designed primarily to embody those positions. The sharper material comes when prejudice appears indirectly—in worries about property, schools, safety, reputation, or whether helping has gone “too far.” Those quieter forms of resistance are much more unsettling than openly unsympathetic characters because they show how easily respectable language can disguise self-interest.
The later escalation gives the novel considerably more momentum than its opening sections. What began as a question of temporary housing becomes connected to marriage, friendship, public attention, and consequences Dalia cannot control. The story works best here because almost every available option carries a cost. Helping more may endanger people close to her; withdrawing help means accepting a system she already believes is failing. The book does not provide a comfortable formula for resolving that contradiction.
What I Liked
The strongest part is the collision between Dalia’s family history and her present privilege. The novel does not allow shared experiences of migration to erase enormous differences in money, citizenship, housing, and safety. I also liked that helping Hajira creates consequences instead of functioning as an uncomplicated act of goodness. That makes the story useful as both family drama and a broader examination of moral responsibility.
What Could Be Better
Several supporting characters are drawn too broadly, particularly when the novel needs someone to represent wealth, indifference, or anti-refugee attitudes. Publishers Weekly raised a similar concern about stock characterization, and it is the clearest limitation of the novel. Dalia is more complicated, but some of her decisions also needed deeper emotional groundwork for the later escalation to feel completely organic.
Context Behind the Book
Saba Brelvi is a Muslim American writer from California. She earned a BA from Brown University and an MPH from Johns Hopkins University and has worked in the nonprofit sector for more than two decades. She currently lives in Abu Dhabi with her family. The Squatters is her debut novel, and her professional background gives particular relevance to a story concerned with nonprofit institutions, displacement, community responsibility, and the distance between good intentions and practical outcomes.