The Priory of the Orange Tree book cover by Samantha Shannon
⏱️
Estimated Read Time
22-28 hours

The Priory of the Orange Tree Review

✍️ Book by Samantha Shannon
Shadab's Rating
★★★★☆ 4.4 (editorial rating)
Tap to Rate
Published2019-02-26
SeriesThe Roots of Chaos
GenreEpic Fantasy, LGBTQ+ Fiction
LanguageEnglish
PublisherBloomsbury Publishing
ISBN-101635570298
ISBN-139781635570298

📝The Priory of the Orange Tree — My Honest Review

Written and reviewed by . The opinions and rating in this review are my own.

Summary:

Queendoms, secret orders, dragon riders, and divided religious traditions must confront the return of an ancient enemy. Ead's divided loyalty and Sabran's growth center the western story, while Tané presents another view of duty and ambition. What follows is a story concerned with power, faith, historical distortion, duty, love, inheritance, and the political use of myth, told through pressure on trust, identity, and ordinary decisions.

✅ What I Liked

I liked the women-led political world, dragons, large lore, and slow development of trust between Ead and Sabran. Ead's divided loyalty and Sabran's growth center the western story, while Tané presents another view of duty and ambition. Those details gave The Priory of the Orange Tree a distinct emotional shape, and the writing trusted the scenes instead of explaining every idea twice.

❌ What Could Be Better

My main problem was that the eastern storyline receives less depth, and the final conflict resolves faster than its buildup suggests. The Priory of the Orange Tree remained readable, but those choices reduced the force of scenes that should have landed harder.

I was not convinced by every part of The Priory of the Orange Tree, but the sections built around the women-led political world carried the weaker stretches.

Queendoms, secret orders, dragon riders, and divided religious traditions must confront the return of an ancient enemy. What interested me was the gap between the rule of the story and the private price of power, visible most clearly in the women-led political world.

My main reservation is that the eastern storyline receives less depth, and the final conflict resolves faster than its buildup suggests. This is where I could see the author's plan around power more clearly than the character's need.

I became most involved through the people caught in power, especially around the women-led political world. Ead's divided loyalty and Sabran's growth center the western story, while Tané presents another view of duty and ambition. This is where my sympathy became complicated rather than automatic, because faith carries a real cost.

The sections I enjoyed most involved the women-led political world, dragons, large lore, and slow development of trust between Ead and Sabran. Those sections find a rhythm that suits the book's interest in faith.

The larger subject is power, faith, historical distortion, duty, love, inheritance, and the political use of myth. I appreciated that power is tied to money, family, work, and the women-led political world rather than left as an abstract idea.

I also noticed how often power appears through routine while faith remains unspoken.

My rating is 4.4/5. The ending left me with power, not with a neat sense that every problem had been solved.

💡 Context Behind The Book

Samantha Shannon is a British fantasy writer known for large-scale world-building and women-centered speculative fiction about myths inherited and challenged.

📊Shadab's Rating

4.4
★★★★
Editor Rating · No community ratings yet

No community ratings yet. The score shown above is the editor's rating. Be the first reader to rate this book.

Tap a star to rate this book

🎭Vibe Check

What's the vibe of this book?
💬 Join the Readers' Discussion

Read spoilers, debates, and detailed user reviews in our discussion room.